clock menu more-arrow no yes
A woman in a white sweater and leather boots holding a large pie topped with pecans.
Haywire’s Route 66 Pecan Pie
Haywire

Where to Find the Best Pies in DFW

Let the pastry experts be in charge of holiday baking this year

View as Map
Haywire’s Route 66 Pecan Pie
| Haywire

Wherever your dessert allegiances lie, there’s no disputing the universal appeal of sweet, delicious pie. The combination of creamy custard or fresh fruit tucked into a buttery, flaky crust is undeniably one of life’s greatest pleasures.

With the holidays right around the corner, there’s no better time to revisit the best pie-makers in Dallas. Consider these 20 pie shops, bakeries, and restaurants for a perfect ending to a delicious holiday meal.

Read More
Note: Restaurants on this map are listed geographically.

1. Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop

Copy Link
1707 N Collins St #115
Arlington, TX 76011
(817) 617-2046
Visit Website

With seven locations in North Texas alone, pies at this shop include classic pumpkin, Southern custard, a chocolate studded I-40 pie, and many more. Keep in mind that Buttermilk Sky Pie also ships to anywhere in the lower 48 starting at $26 per pie.

2. JudyPie

Copy Link
520 S Main St #200
Grapevine, TX 76051
(817) 400-7437
Visit Website

Judy Pie in Grapevine offers a selection of fall flavors like Punky Pumpkin, cherry, chocolate cream, and strawberry rhubarb. Call (817) 400-7437 to order 6-inch or 10-inch pies, for $15 and $40, respectively.

3. Hive Bakery

Copy Link
360 Parker Square Rd
Flower Mound, TX 75028
(972) 316-7625
Visit Website

Hive Bakery in Flower Mound gets a bit of buzz thanks to its custom cakes, but the pies are also worth checking out. Find pumpkin, bourbon pecan chocolate chip, pecan, apple, dutch apple, peach, blueberry and chocolate cream, all of which can be ordered online for November 24 pickup. Note that the bakery also has gluten-free and vegan options available.

View this post on Instagram

We have slices of Blueberry Pie today!!! ✨ ✨

A post shared by Hive Bakery (@hivebakery) on

4. Norma's Cafe

Copy Link
1123 W Davis St
Dallas, TX 75208
(214) 946-4711
Visit Website

This classic diner is famous for its selection of meringue-topped fruit and cream pies at all five DFW locations. Go for the chocolate peanut butter if you need a serious indulgence, or stick with a classic lemon for a lighter treat.

Norma's Cafe/Facebook

5. Celebration

Copy Link
4503 W Lovers Ln
Dallas, TX 75209
(214) 351-5681
Visit Website

Dallas’ quintessential home cooking restaurant, Celebration offers several pies to choose from alongside its Southern specialties like pot roast, meatloaf and fried chicken. Visit the ,arket next door to pick up pumpkin, pecan, apple, chocolate cream, coconut cream, or key lime pies starting at $20 each.

6. Emporium Pies

Copy Link
314 N Bishop Ave
Dallas, TX 75208
(469) 206-6126
Visit Website

Whether you’re more of a chocolate lover (Smooth Operator), or a classic apple guy (Lord of the Pies), a beautiful slice — or whole pie — awaits at Emporium Pies, available for pickup or delivery from each of the pie purveyor’s four DFW-area shops. Need to send some little freshly-baked love to someone outside of DFW? Emporium ships nationwide. The Bishop Arts shop has a “pie-thru” window to make pickups even smoother.

Emporium Pies

7. Mama's Daughters' Diner

Copy Link
2014 Irving Blvd
Dallas, TX 75207
(214) 742-8646
Visit Website

No trip to a retro diner is complete without a slice of pie. Luckily Mama’s Daughters’ has a wide selection of sweets including cobblers, meringue pies, cream pies, and traditional pies to choose from at its multiple DFW outposts. Visit mamasdaughtersdiner.com for the Thanksgiving order form.

8. Haywire

Copy Link
7401 Windrose Ave
Plano, TX 75024
(972) 781-9473
Visit Website

Haywire at Legacy West offers a three-pound Route 66 Pecan Pie, which is a pecan pie made with a cinnamon roll crust. That’s a pie crust made out of cinnamon rolls, which may make this pie a truly perfect food. It’s available to order whole, through December 22, for $45

9. Spiral Diner & Bakery

Copy Link
1101 N Beckley Ave
Dallas, TX 75203
(214) 948-4747
Visit Website

No one will ever question vegan sweets again after trying one of Spiral Diner’s vegan pies. Spiral’s holiday pie selections this year include sweet potato, blueberry, and pecan.

10. Empire Baking Company

Copy Link
5450 W Lovers Ln #132
Dallas, TX 75209
(214) 350-0007
Visit Website

Specializing in baked goods to take away and baking bread for what seems like half the restaurants in town, Empire offers a trio of classic pies for the holidays. Pumpkin, Texas pecan and apple-cranberry are all on offer, priced from $27 to $29. Online pie ordering is available at empirebaking.com.

11. Unrefined Bakery

Copy Link
6055 Sherry Ln
Dallas, TX 75225
(469) 816-2414
Visit Website

For those with dietary concerns, finding the right pie can be a challenge. Fortunately, Unrefined can whip up a gluten-free, dairy-free, or paleo version of your classic favorite, and it will taste just as good as the original. The paleo French silk pie is a particularly good example that healthy pies don't have to taste boring.

12. Uncle Willie's Pies

Copy Link
600 Methodist St
Red Oak, TX 75154
(972) 576-5582
Visit Website

A player in the wedding and catering world, Uncle Willie’s Pies are classic and scratch-made. Flavors like dutch caramel apple, sweet potato, and buttermilk chess are perfect for the holidays. No-sugar-added pies will please those looking to cut down on the sweet stuff. Order online by November 19 at unclewilliespies.com.

13. Bisous Bisous Pâtisserie

Copy Link
3700 McKinney Ave #150
Dallas, TX 75204
(214) 613-3570
Visit Website

Bisous Bisous is known for its French macarons, but the traditional bakery’s pies are not to be underestimated. Apple streusel and classic pumpkin pies join chocolate pecan tarts to round out the bakery’s stellar holiday lineup. For those who prefer that fresh-baked taste at home without the effort, Bisous’ freezer to oven versions come in clutch.

14. The Rustic

Copy Link
3656 Howell St
Dallas, TX 75204
(214) 730-0596
Visit Website

The Rustic’s famous peanut butter pie might not be the most traditional choice for your Thanksgiving dessert table, but it just might be one of the most decadent pies in town. The live music venue/restaurant also makes a mean butterscotch pie. Call your nearest Rustic location to order.

15. Val's Cheesecakes, The Shop

Copy Link
2820 Greenville Ave
Dallas, TX 75206
(469) 776-8044
Visit Website

The cheesecake-based shop, shack and stand on Greenville Avenue, Maple and in Fort Worth is offering up freshly baked cheesecake-pie hybrids for Thanksgiving. Try an oatmeal cream pie cheesecake or pumpkin pie cheesecake, each of which will wow your guests.

16. Leila Bakery & Cafe

Copy Link
6041 Oram St
Dallas, TX 75206
(972) 807-6297
Visit Website

This little shop on Oram in Lakewood is turning out some serious pastries. Order up a gingerbread-pumpkin pie for pickup on Wednesday, November 24. While you’re there, snag a quiche or some kolaches for Thanksgiving morning, all baked fresh daily.

17. La Casita Bakeshop

Copy Link
580 W Arapaho Rd Suite 230
Richardson, TX 75080
(440) 462-2078
Visit Website

La Casita Bakeshop in Richardson is baking up more than just its regular pastries, cookies and breads now that it’s pie season. In addition to classic pumpkin, they’ve got chocolate hazelnut tarts, and pecan praline pumpkin, winter grapefruit, and brown butter apple pies. Order online at lacasitabakeshop.com.

18. Humble: Simply Good Pies

Copy Link
9014 Garland Rd
Dallas, TX 75218
(214) 458-9039
Visit Website

Humble on Garland Road in East Dallas specializes in classic flavors done just right. Order an old-fashioned apple, cherry, pumpkin, sweet potato, or bourbon-chocolate-pecan pie, or a more unique Bayou Goo or Blossom’s Coconut Joy. Order online from their Thanksgiving page.

19. Nature's Plate

Copy Link
10233 E NW Hwy #432
Dallas, TX 75238
(469) 307-4217
Visit Website

Whether you’ve got vegans in the house or not, a pumpkin pie from Nature’s Plate won’t disappoint. Nature’s Plate crafts shockingly delicious vegan pies made from wholesome ingredients like cashews, maple syrup, pumpkin, pecan, and gluten-free oats. This year Nature’s Plate has added Mini Pumpkin Pies in traditional pumpkin, pumpkin cheesecake, or chocolate cheesecake. Deliveries are available on the Tuesday or Wednesday before Thanksgiving. Order online.

Rachel Pinn

20. Sweet J’s Pies

Copy Link
2904 San Medina Ave
Dallas, TX 75228

Specializing in mini pies, full-sized pies, English toffee and themed cupcakes, Sweet J’s turns out personal and full-sized pies in flavors like chocolate chess, apple caramel crumble, triple berry and chocolate ganache available for delivery. Order by November 19 for Thanksgiving pickup.

1. Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop

1707 N Collins St #115, Arlington, TX 76011

With seven locations in North Texas alone, pies at this shop include classic pumpkin, Southern custard, a chocolate studded I-40 pie, and many more. Keep in mind that Buttermilk Sky Pie also ships to anywhere in the lower 48 starting at $26 per pie.

1707 N Collins St #115
Arlington, TX 76011

2. JudyPie

520 S Main St #200, Grapevine, TX 76051

Judy Pie in Grapevine offers a selection of fall flavors like Punky Pumpkin, cherry, chocolate cream, and strawberry rhubarb. Call (817) 400-7437 to order 6-inch or 10-inch pies, for $15 and $40, respectively.

520 S Main St #200
Grapevine, TX 76051

3. Hive Bakery

360 Parker Square Rd, Flower Mound, TX 75028

Hive Bakery in Flower Mound gets a bit of buzz thanks to its custom cakes, but the pies are also worth checking out. Find pumpkin, bourbon pecan chocolate chip, pecan, apple, dutch apple, peach, blueberry and chocolate cream, all of which can be ordered online for November 24 pickup. Note that the bakery also has gluten-free and vegan options available.

360 Parker Square Rd
Flower Mound, TX 75028

4. Norma's Cafe

1123 W Davis St, Dallas, TX 75208
Norma's Cafe/Facebook

This classic diner is famous for its selection of meringue-topped fruit and cream pies at all five DFW locations. Go for the chocolate peanut butter if you need a serious indulgence, or stick with a classic lemon for a lighter treat.

1123 W Davis St
Dallas, TX 75208

5. Celebration

4503 W Lovers Ln, Dallas, TX 75209

Dallas’ quintessential home cooking restaurant, Celebration offers several pies to choose from alongside its Southern specialties like pot roast, meatloaf and fried chicken. Visit the ,arket next door to pick up pumpkin, pecan, apple, chocolate cream, coconut cream, or key lime pies starting at $20 each.

4503 W Lovers Ln
Dallas, TX 75209

6. Emporium Pies

314 N Bishop Ave, Dallas, TX 75208
Emporium Pies

Whether you’re more of a chocolate lover (Smooth Operator), or a classic apple guy (Lord of the Pies), a beautiful slice — or whole pie — awaits at Emporium Pies, available for pickup or delivery from each of the pie purveyor’s four DFW-area shops. Need to send some little freshly-baked love to someone outside of DFW? Emporium ships nationwide. The Bishop Arts shop has a “pie-thru” window to make pickups even smoother.

314 N Bishop Ave
Dallas, TX 75208

7. Mama's Daughters' Diner

2014 Irving Blvd, Dallas, TX 75207

No trip to a retro diner is complete without a slice of pie. Luckily Mama’s Daughters’ has a wide selection of sweets including cobblers, meringue pies, cream pies, and traditional pies to choose from at its multiple DFW outposts. Visit mamasdaughtersdiner.com for the Thanksgiving order form.

2014 Irving Blvd
Dallas, TX 75207

8. Haywire

7401 Windrose Ave, Plano, TX 75024

Haywire at Legacy West offers a three-pound Route 66 Pecan Pie, which is a pecan pie made with a cinnamon roll crust. That’s a pie crust made out of cinnamon rolls, which may make this pie a truly perfect food. It’s available to order whole, through December 22, for $45

7401 Windrose Ave
Plano, TX 75024

9. Spiral Diner & Bakery

1101 N Beckley Ave, Dallas, TX 75203

No one will ever question vegan sweets again after trying one of Spiral Diner’s vegan pies. Spiral’s holiday pie selections this year include sweet potato, blueberry, and pecan.

1101 N Beckley Ave
Dallas, TX 75203

10. Empire Baking Company

5450 W Lovers Ln #132, Dallas, TX 75209

Specializing in baked goods to take away and baking bread for what seems like half the restaurants in town, Empire offers a trio of classic pies for the holidays. Pumpkin, Texas pecan and apple-cranberry are all on offer, priced from $27 to $29. Online pie ordering is available at empirebaking.com.

5450 W Lovers Ln #132
Dallas, TX 75209

11. Unrefined Bakery

6055 Sherry Ln, Dallas, TX 75225

For those with dietary concerns, finding the right pie can be a challenge. Fortunately, Unrefined can whip up a gluten-free, dairy-free, or paleo version of your classic favorite, and it will taste just as good as the original. The paleo French silk pie is a particularly good example that healthy pies don't have to taste boring.

6055 Sherry Ln
Dallas, TX 75225

12. Uncle Willie's Pies

600 Methodist St, Red Oak, TX 75154

A player in the wedding and catering world, Uncle Willie’s Pies are classic and scratch-made. Flavors like dutch caramel apple, sweet potato, and buttermilk chess are perfect for the holidays. No-sugar-added pies will please those looking to cut down on the sweet stuff. Order online by November 19 at unclewilliespies.com.

600 Methodist St
Red Oak, TX 75154

13. Bisous Bisous Pâtisserie

3700 McKinney Ave #150, Dallas, TX 75204

Bisous Bisous is known for its French macarons, but the traditional bakery’s pies are not to be underestimated. Apple streusel and classic pumpkin pies join chocolate pecan tarts to round out the bakery’s stellar holiday lineup. For those who prefer that fresh-baked taste at home without the effort, Bisous’ freezer to oven versions come in clutch.

3700 McKinney Ave #150
Dallas, TX 75204

14. The Rustic

3656 Howell St, Dallas, TX 75204

The Rustic’s famous peanut butter pie might not be the most traditional choice for your Thanksgiving dessert table, but it just might be one of the most decadent pies in town. The live music venue/restaurant also makes a mean butterscotch pie. Call your nearest Rustic location to order.

3656 Howell St
Dallas, TX 75204

15. Val's Cheesecakes, The Shop

2820 Greenville Ave, Dallas, TX 75206

The cheesecake-based shop, shack and stand on Greenville Avenue, Maple and in Fort Worth is offering up freshly baked cheesecake-pie hybrids for Thanksgiving. Try an oatmeal cream pie cheesecake or pumpkin pie cheesecake, each of which will wow your guests.

2820 Greenville Ave
Dallas, TX 75206

Related Maps

16. Leila Bakery & Cafe

6041 Oram St, Dallas, TX 75206

This little shop on Oram in Lakewood is turning out some serious pastries. Order up a gingerbread-pumpkin pie for pickup on Wednesday, November 24. While you’re there, snag a quiche or some kolaches for Thanksgiving morning, all baked fresh daily.

6041 Oram St
Dallas, TX 75206

17. La Casita Bakeshop

580 W Arapaho Rd Suite 230, Richardson, TX 75080

La Casita Bakeshop in Richardson is baking up more than just its regular pastries, cookies and breads now that it’s pie season. In addition to classic pumpkin, they’ve got chocolate hazelnut tarts, and pecan praline pumpkin, winter grapefruit, and brown butter apple pies. Order online at lacasitabakeshop.com.

580 W Arapaho Rd Suite 230
Richardson, TX 75080

18. Humble: Simply Good Pies

9014 Garland Rd, Dallas, TX 75218

Humble on Garland Road in East Dallas specializes in classic flavors done just right. Order an old-fashioned apple, cherry, pumpkin, sweet potato, or bourbon-chocolate-pecan pie, or a more unique Bayou Goo or Blossom’s Coconut Joy. Order online from their Thanksgiving page.

9014 Garland Rd
Dallas, TX 75218

19. Nature's Plate

10233 E NW Hwy #432, Dallas, TX 75238
Rachel Pinn

Whether you’ve got vegans in the house or not, a pumpkin pie from Nature’s Plate won’t disappoint. Nature’s Plate crafts shockingly delicious vegan pies made from wholesome ingredients like cashews, maple syrup, pumpkin, pecan, and gluten-free oats. This year Nature’s Plate has added Mini Pumpkin Pies in traditional pumpkin, pumpkin cheesecake, or chocolate cheesecake. Deliveries are available on the Tuesday or Wednesday before Thanksgiving. Order online.

10233 E NW Hwy #432
Dallas, TX 75238

20. Sweet J’s Pies

2904 San Medina Ave, Dallas, TX 75228

Specializing in mini pies, full-sized pies, English toffee and themed cupcakes, Sweet J’s turns out personal and full-sized pies in flavors like chocolate chess, apple caramel crumble, triple berry and chocolate ganache available for delivery. Order by November 19 for Thanksgiving pickup.

2904 San Medina Ave
Dallas, TX 75228

Related Maps